Skip to main content

Reset your password

Please enter the e-mail address you used to register to reset your password

Note: The verification e-mail to change your password should arrive immediately. However, in some cases it takes longer. Don't forget to check your spam folder.

If you haven't received the e-mail in 24 hours, please contact customerservices@ioppublishing.org

Registration complete

Thank you for registering with Physics World
If you'd like to change your details at any time, please visit My account

Close
Home » Page 27

Metasurface grating gives solar telescopes a boost

A compact optical technology that has already proved its worth in Earth-bound applications could be on its way to space after researchers at the University of California San Diego, US showed that it can map the Sun’s magnetic field just as well as traditional instruments. By making polarization gratings from specially engineered metasurfaces rather than a complex assembly of optics, the researchers say that future solar-observing missions could benefit from reduced complexity and cost as well as size.

“Our work makes use of recent advancements in nanoscale optical technologies to help improve the hardware for making astronomical observations of the Sun,” says study leader Noah Rubin of UC San Diego’s Jacobs School of Engineering. “We believe this is one of the first times that metasurface optics – which have been a subject of intense interest in both academic research and industry for about a decade – have been used to improve scientific instrumentation of any kind outside of a lab/academic proof-of-concept.”

Polarized light and solar magnetic fields

Although light emitted by the Sun is generally unpolarized – that is, the light waves do not vibrate along a particular axis – strong magnetic fields that develop near sunspots can polarize this light via the quantum mechanical Zeeman effect. These magnetic fields are closely associated with space weather events such as solar storms that can damage electronic infrastructure both on Earth and in orbit. Studying the Sun’s magnetic activity by monitoring areas of polarized light is thus an important step towards detecting or predicting such storms in time to take protective action.

Usually, measuring the polarization state of light means analysing different polarization directions using a device such as a waveplate that mechanically rotates between exposures. Rubin compares this process to taking several photographs through polarized sunglasses held at different angles, then combining them to obtain a fuller picture of what’s going on.

Photo of the custom-built telescope being tested at the Dunn Solar Telescope
Test rig: Sunlight from the top of the Dunn Solar Telescope’s 136-foot-tall tower travels 228 feet underground and is reflected back up to this room at ground level, where it passes through an optical system (blue lights, background) before reaching the team’s custom-built telescope (foreground). (Courtesy: Noah Rubin)

While this technique works, and instruments that use it have already been sent into space, the image analysis process is very time-consuming. It also requires an external power source, and the need to mechanically rotate the waveplate introduces extra complexity and cost, says Rubin.

“In space-based applications, a satellite itself can be moving while this component reorients, causing a highly undesirable blurring effect,” he explains. “As a result, designers of these systems often invest considerable resources into mechanical remediation and engineering to correct the motion of the telescope on the satellite, and this frequently ends up being substantially more expensive than the telescope optics themselves.”

A metasurface solution

In the new study, which is detailed in Science Advances, Rubin and colleagues solved this problem by creating a polarization-sensitive metasurface that splits light into its different polarization components. A camera-like system containing this metasurface polarization grating can then form multiple images of a scene in parallel. Rubin explains that each image in this scene is analysed with respect to a different polarization state, meaning that the system can measure the polarization of light simultaneously and passively in a single camera frame.

Rubin notes that this technique of condensing an instrument that would ordinarily involve a complex assembly of optics into a single, flat surface has previously made its way into applications as diverse as facial recognition in mobile phones and the preparation of complex photon states in quantum optics experiments. “In this work, we show that these advantages translate to polarization imaging in astronomy,” he tells Physics World.

Comparable results

Working with industrial partners at BAE Systems Space & Mission Systems in Colorado, US (formerly known as Ball Aerospace, which Rubin describes as “well-known for its involvement in the development of the James Webb Space Telescope, Hubble and countless other NASA missions”), the team designed a specialized telescope built around such a metasurface polarization grating. They also deployed their instrument on the Dunn Solar Telescope in New Mexico, US, and showed that they could quantitatively map the magnetic fields in sunspots by capturing simultaneous polarization images of these spots.

The researchers report that their results were comparable to those obtained by the state-of-the-art NASA Solar Dynamics Observatory mission in-orbit, highlighting what Rubin calls “the significant advantages that these metasurface components can offer when designed in conjunction with more traditional optical systems”. The UC San Diego team is now exploring ways of integrating its technology into future NASA solar-observing space missions.

Satellite-based sensor system designed to detect nuclear weapons in space

For decades, the Outer Space Treaty (OST) has prevented any nation from placing nuclear weapons in space. To date, however, no mechanisms have been put in place to determine whether a signing member’s satellite may be violating this treaty, or even developing other nuclear capabilities that the original treaty never considered.

Through new analysis of the problem, Areg Danagoulian at MIT suggests a safe and feasible approach to monitoring suspicious satellites, using neutrons emitted as radioactive material is impacted by naturally occurring protons in the Van Allen radiation belt.

At the height of the Cold War in the 1960s, there seemed a growing possibility that space could be used as a platform for developing nuclear weapons. With the prospect of nuclear strikes being launched from orbit with practically no warning, both the US and Soviet governments recognised the possibility of miscalculations by either side leading to a catastrophic nuclear conflict.

In 1967, this led to the signing of the OST: which in part, demands that no signing member should ever deploy nuclear weapons in orbit, on celestial bodies or in outer space. Today, it has been signed by 117 countries, including the US, Russia and China. However, in the decades since the treaty’s origins, both political and technological landscapes have profoundly transformed, creating entirely new concerns that nobody could have conceived in the 1960s.

“In 2022, Russia launched the Kosmos 2553 satellite, which the US has determined is a platform for testing components for a future nuclear anti-satellite weapon,” Danagoulian says. With the ability to target orbiting satellites, such a programme could ultimately destroy vital communication and navigation systems – bringing society to a standstill without any direct strike on the ground.

Despite this threat, no robust mechanism has ever been developed for verifying whether a country is violating the OST, and to date, very little research has even considered the problem.

To Danagoulian’s knowledge, the only related study was an undergraduate thesis by Stanford University student Isobel Portenous – who proposed that suspicious satellites could be probed for nuclear material by measuring radioactivity in the vicinity. However, not only is space already highly radioactive, likely drowning out the signal from a single satellite; it would also require spacecraft to closely approach the satellite, which could be interpreted as a hostile act.

To address this challenge, Danagoulian considered how satellites could instead by probed by naturally occurring, highly energetic protons in the Van Allen radiation belt: which mostly originate from the solar wind, and become trapped by Earth’s magnetosphere.

When interacting with nuclear material in a suspect satellite, “these protons would trigger a process known as spallation in the uranium radiation case of the thermonuclear weapon,” Danagoulian explains. “This would produce a large flux of neutrons that can be detected and used as a fairly specific signature of a nuclear weapon.”

Crucially, the kind of device needed to detect these neutrons wouldn’t need to be too close to the satellite. From a distance of 4 km, Danagoulian calculated that a standard CubeSat detection platform could accurately determine the composition of the nuclear payload of a satellite like Kosmos 2553, within just a week of measurement time.

For now, much more work will be needed before this kind of mechanism can be realistically applied. “Uncertainty remains regarding whether this approach will be practical, so much work is still needed,” Danagoulian says. “Can one build a reliable detector array to perform this measurement? That’s to be determined.”

Yet if these hurdles can be overcome, they could provide a valuable new layer of security in a fast-changing world, and could potentially guide new international policy decisions. “The required physics and basic technology are available to solve this problem,” Danagoulian continues. “If an inspector satellite can be built, it will finally create a mechanism for verifying the OST.”

The study is reported in Nature.

In the age of AI, we must double down on the skills that make us experts

In 2008 the US author Neal Stephenson published a speculative fiction novel called Anathem. Set on the fictional planet of Arbre, the story follows an order of monks, mostly isolated from the rest of the world, who every so often open up their doors to receive information on the state of the outside world.

In the book, Stephenson explores a Dark Age of the Internet, in which companies flood the network with plausible-sounding-but-false information in a ploy to force consumers to buy the firms’ own tools for distinguishing truth from falsehood.

Initially, this “crap”, as Stephenson calls it, had to be made by humans, but eventually the process is run by a so-called “Artificial Inanity”, which is able to create hundreds or thousands of bogus versions, or “bogons”, for every legitimate document.

Today, we face our own version of Stephenson’s Dark Age as our information landscape increasingly fills with AI slop, now going beyond AI-generated videos of uncanny kittens or images depicting politicians and celebrities in outlandish situations.

With the rise of chatbots powered by large language models (LLMs), our search results, social-media feeds and even scientific journals are getting polluted with data that, at first glance, appears relevant and plausible but contains no value beneath its gilded veneer.

As LLM-generated slop infects our previously trusted knowledge base, we face an information landscape that is quickly rotting beneath us.

As scientists, we must position our work in relation to other recent research. Yet that task gets harder when we have to sort out the real from the hallucinated. As LLM-generated slop infects our previously trusted knowledge base, we face an information landscape that is quickly rotting beneath us.

Where we could once track an idea to a paper with human authors (who bore consequences for acts of fraud), we face a future where we have to question whether an article’s authors, institutions or experiments ever existed, on top of evaluating its scientific merits.

This is not a hypothetical danger. In 2024 a team led by medical researcher Almira Osmanovic Thunström at the University of Gothenburg invented a fictitious medical condition called “bixonimania” and publicized it through posts on Medium and two pre-print papers.

Their goal was to test whether AI chatbots would pick up and propagate word of the fake disease, which they duly did. The researchers even tried to insert information that made the work obviously fake. This included acknowledging a colleague from Starfleet Academy, thanking the University of Fellowship of the Ring for funding, and even writing early on in the article that “this entire paper is made up”.

Trapped in a bog

As physicists, we are not immune to the dangers of information rot. A flood of LLM-generated articles prompted arXiv in May to announce consequences for authors whose submissions have “incontrovertible evidence that the authors did not check the results of LLM generation”, including having “hallucinated references”. Those consequences include a one-year ban from arXiv and the requirement, thereafter, that any submitted paper must already be accepted at a “reputable peer-reviewed venue”.

I initially welcomed the news. Harsh consequences are one way to discourage LLM usage, especially for sloppy shortcuts. But the more I reflect on it, the more I realize that arXiv’s consequences could eventually fall even on those who are not using LLMs to write their papers.

Relying on shortcuts is easy. Say you’re writing a literature review and paper A, which you’ve read and trust, has a fact you want to cite – but you notice that paper A cites paper B for this fact. It’s simple to scroll down to the reference section and copy paper B’s citation into your own citations (I would be lying if I said I’ve never done this myself).

But as the information landscape rots, this shortcut could run you afoul of policies like arXiv’s. What appears to be a valid citation – maybe even containing the names of authors you know personally – can be hallucinated.

We must double down on the skills that make us experts – our scientific judgement, information literacy, communication skills and careful scholarship.

Or it could be entirely fake, as a team of researchers who cited one of the “bixonimania” pre-prints in a peer-reviewed article discovered. Their paper was justifiably retracted by the journal editor, over their objections. By simply copying a reference without double-checking it, you can unintentionally join ranks alongside LLM users. Worse, you open yourself and all of your co-authors to being banned from arXiv.

I am not suggesting that arXiv’s policy is flawed. Rather, I argue that those who intend their writing to be AI-free must be vigilant. We must double down on the skills that make us experts – our scientific judgement, information literacy, communication skills and careful scholarship. We should lean into practising these skills – and teaching them – even though they are precisely the skills that AI companies claim LLMs can replace.

In Anathem, a character simply hand-waves away their Internet full of bogons, but we have no such solution. Instead, as our information landscape rots, we find ourselves trapped in a bog. To get out, we must plan each step carefully and take none for granted. What appears to be solid ground may well prove treacherous. Moving safely is a slow process, full of checking and double-checking as we painstakingly build out paths and tools we can trust.

Simply choosing not to use an LLM when writing is no longer enough. We have only our own scholarly skills to sort the bogons from the ground truth. We will all have to slow down if we want out of the bog.

Metamaterial boosts heat transfer on the nanoscale

Specially engineered materials known as metamaterials can boost heat transfer over nanoscale distances compared with conventional materials, thanks to the coupling of quasiparticles known as surface phonon polaritons. This new result, from researchers at Carnegie Mellon University, Stanford University and Purdue University, all in the US, could help improve technologies such as on-chip cooling and thermophotovoltaic systems.

The maximum radiative heat transfer between two macroscopic-sized objects at different temperatures can be estimated by assuming that the objects are “black bodies”. These are ideal entities that absorb all the radiation falling on them and emit thermal radiation according to Planck’s law. This approximation breaks down, however, when the objects are placed within a few hundred nanometres of each other. In this case, they begin to exchange heat much more strongly thanks to a phenomenon known as near-field enhancement, which can exceed the far-field black body limit by several orders of magnitude. This effect is already put to good use in technologies such as heat extraction and thermophotovoltaic systems.

Until now, near-field enhancement had only been observed and studied in naturally occurring materials, such as polar dielectrics, doped semiconductors and metals, explain the study leaders, mechanical engineer Sheng Shen at Carnegie Mellon and electrical engineer Shanhui Fan from Stanford. Although theoretical studies have predicted that metamaterials could surpass the performance limits of naturally occurring materials, there had not previously been any experimental demonstration of metamaterial-enhanced near-field radiative heat transfer. Identifying such metamaterials would be of great use as it would allow the effect to be exploited more widely.

Heat transfer increased by up to four times

Shen, Fan and colleagues observed enhanced near-field radiative heat transfer in a nanodevice platform comprising metamaterials based on arrays of gold split-ring resonators patterned on silicon nitride membranes. The researchers positioned the metamaterials so that they faced each other across a nanoscale gap, observing that heat transfer between them increased by as much as four times compared with similar setups using ordinary materials.

As well as confirming that radiative heat transfer is enhanced over short distances for these metamaterials, the results suggest that the interaction between metamaterials and surface phonon polaritons is responsible for the increase. These quasiparticles are produced by phonons, which are vibrations of the crystalline lattice, as they interact with oscillating electromagnetic fields at the material surface – in this case, those at the surface of the gold metamaterial structures. This coupling allows heat to tunnel across the gap between them and the silicon nitride membranes more efficiently – something that increases the energy flow between the two, explains Shen.

Heat management applications

According to the researchers, the effect could help enhance and manipulate heat exchange at the nanoscale and could find applications in next-generation cooling for high-performance microelectronics, thermophotovoltaic systems for waste-heat harvesting and high-sensitivity infrared detection.

There are still a number of challenges to overcome before such applications see the light of day, however. On the theoretical side, notes Fan, the complex interactions between the metamaterial units and their supporting substrate make numerical calculations and analyses exceptionally difficult. “To address this difficulty, we have developed a numerical tool based on fluctuational electrodynamics to design the structures, alongside a coupled-mode theory model to fully elucidate the underlying physics,” he says.

Experimentally, measuring nanowatt-level radiative heat exchange across a sub-micron gap also demands extreme precision. The researchers tackled this challenge by designing an on-chip device using a “suspended thermal bridge” method that transforms the minute heat exchange into a measurable temperature rise. Indeed, they succeeded in detecting heat flow of less than 1 nW in these nanodevices.

They report their work in Nature.

Quiz of the week: what techniques can be combined to predict the frequency of extreme weather events?

Fancy some more? Check out our puzzles page.

Study reveals the energy cost of Hannibal’s Alpine crossing

It is one of the most extraordinary feats of military history – how the Carthaginian general Hannibal managed to cross the Alps with an army of 46,000 men, 7000 horses and 37 war elephants in 218 BCE.

Hannibal’s method was to catch the Romans by surprise by starting from what is present-day France and crossing the Alps into what is now northern Italy.

Yet the exact route that Hannibal’s army took remains a mystery and has been debated for decades given that no records by contemporary historians have survived.

Now theoretical ecologist Emilio Berti from the German Centre for Integrative Biodiversity Research Halle-Jena-Leipzig and Fritz Vollrath at the University of Oxford, UK, have calculated the metabolic cost that the army would have incurred via several possible mountain passes.

The route crossing Col du Clapier – passing first through Grenoble and Aiton before descending into the Po Valley – appeared to be the likely candidate, but recent analysis has suggested an alternative southerly route via the Col de la Traversette.

Using route modelling and elevation data, the team found that the Col du Clapier route would have required 6.28 × 1012 joules of energy, while Col de la Traversette, however, would have needed 5.42 × 1012 J.

Yet even on that route, the 15-day crossing would have required 230 tonnes of food and supplies.

The authors calculate that the army would still have lost about a fifth of their body fat reserves during the crossing, which explains the high mortality rate among men.

Yet on the Col de la Traversette route, the war elephants would have fared better, losing just 4% of their reserves. This may explain why some 30 elephants are estimated to have made it through to fight in the Battle of the Trebia – the first major battle of the Second Punic War.

“The new analysis does not eliminate all ambiguity, but it does strengthen the case for the Traversette route by demonstrating that it would better accommodate the demands of moving a large army that included elephants through extremely difficult alpine terrain,” notes Berti.

Powerful cosmic winds may have destroyed galaxies in the early universe

A galaxy that formed around a billion years after the Big Bang is in its death throes thanks to a powerful galactic wind that is blasting its gas into space, say astronomers at Australia’s Swinburne University of Technology. The discovery, which is based on data from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) and the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) in Chile, could help explain why some of the universe’s earliest massive galaxies ceased to form new stars.

One of the JWST’s most surprising discoveries is that when the universe was between one and two billion years old, it already contained large numbers of massive galaxies. Astronomers think these galaxies may have acquired most of their mass in intense bursts of star formation. But at some point, that process stopped: in technical terms, the galaxies became quiescent.

“These galaxies seemed to have formed all their stars very quickly and then they suddenly died, all within the first two billion years of the universe being formed,” says Rebecca Davies, who led the new research.

The CRISTAL-02 galaxy

One possible explanation for the onset of quiescence is that when galaxies collide with each other, the resulting winds “blow away” the hydrogen fuel required for new stars to form. To investigate this hypothesis, Davies and colleagues focused on a galaxy called CRISTAL-02, which was one of 20 galaxies in the recent ALMA-CRISTAL survey of early star-forming galaxies.

“When we looked at the data, it stood out because it was the only one that showed strong evidence for a galaxy wind,” Davies explains. “We saw this as an excellent opportunity to study how winds impacted the evolution of galaxies in the early universe.”

The light from CRISTAL-02 travelled for approximately 12.7 billion years to reach us, meaning that we see it as it was one billion years after the Big Bang. Because the universe has been expanding since then, the galaxy’s spectra appear highly red-shifted. This meant the Swinburne astronomers needed the JWST’s infrared-sensing capabilities to analyse a spectral feature known as the hydrogen-alpha (Hα) line that is normally red. They also used ALMA to analyse CRISTAL-02’s C II line, which comes from ionized carbon and has a (non-redshifted) wavelength of 158 mm. Both emission lines can yield important information about the properties of early galaxies.

Living fast and dying young

From the ALMA-CRISTAL survey’s measurements of Hα luminosity, astronomers knew that CRISTAL-02 forms stars at a rate of around 260 M☉ per year. This is about three times the average value for “main-sequence” star-forming galaxies at similar mass and redshifts.

The latest observations, however, suggest that it won’t maintain this pace for long. Davies and colleagues identified a huge plume of C II emissions that extends as far as 7 kiloparsecs (kpc) to the north-east of CRISTAL-02, making it almost as long as the galaxy itself. This is a telltale sign that gas is being driven out of the galaxy. The fact that the gas in this plume is blue-shifted by 100 km s-1 lends further support to this explanation.

If this rapid blowout continues, Davies says that CRISTAL-02 will cease to exist in less than 50 million years. But the team’s findings may have implications beyond the fate of this single galaxy. “Our results could help to explain how some of the earliest massive quiescent galaxies in the universe behave,” she tells Physics World. “When the JWST started observing distant galaxies in 2022, it found far more evolved galaxies in the early universe than models predicted. These galaxies seemed to have formed all their stars very quickly and then suddenly died, all within the first two billion years of the universe. The galaxy we discovered seems to be following this path.”

Learning about the early universe

Davies explains that because the early universe was much more compact than it is now, collisions between galaxies were common. During such collisions, gas funnels towards the galactic centres, triggering strong bursts of star formation but also producing strong winds that eventually drive the gas away. “If many early galaxies collide and experience rapid growth, then it may not be surprising at all that we see so many dead galaxies in the early universe,” she says.

The researchers stress that the present work, which is detailed in the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, is based on a case study of just one galaxy. They now need to observe other early, massive galaxies caught during periods of intense growth to determine whether they, too, experience powerful winds that could rapidly expel their gas and stop them from forming stars.

Static electricity: mysteries lurk within this everyday phenomenon

Static electricity is one of those everyday phenomena that turns out to be much more complicated than you might expect. Indeed, our guest in this episode of the Physics World Weekly podcast has devoted much of his career to understanding how objects exchange electrical charge – a process that he says scientists are mostly “clueless” about.

Based at the Institute of Science and Technology Austria, Scott Waitukaitis is in conversation with Physics World’s Margaret Harris. He explains how his early work in granular physics opened his eyes to the many unsolved problems related to static electricity. They also chat about some of Waitukaitis’s current research projects including his quest to understand the role that adsorbed molecules play in how an object is charged.

Frost spreads across surfaces via suspended ‘ice bridges’

Frost can spread not only along surfaces but also via suspended “ice bridges” that form above them. The discovery of this previously unknown frost-propagation pathway could lead to new ways of making surfaces that resist frost growth, thereby improving the performance of devices that operate in cold, humid environments.

Frost accumulation is a major problem in refrigerators, aeroplanes and heat pumps, to name just a few. On the microscale, it primarily spreads from one individual freezing water droplet to the next via two-dimensional bridges, or causeways, that temporarily form on the surface of an object. Although the wettability of the surface is known to affect the spreading process, the mechanism behind this effect was poorly understood.

Ice bridges can grow in two distinct spatial modes

To learn more, a team led by physicist Nenad Miljkovic at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, US imaged the channel-forming process using high-speed high-resolution optical microscopy combined with a profilometry technique called focal plane shift imaging (FPSI). They found that frost can spread in two distinct ways. On hydrophilic surfaces, causeways form along the substrate, in line with current theoretical models. On superhydrophobic surfaces, however, the situation is quite different. Here, frost spreads via ice bridges that are suspended above the surface in three-dimensional space.

This suspended or “out-of-plane” growth mode represents a fundamentally different pathway for frost propagation, says team member Siyan Yang, the first author of a Nature Physics  paper about the work. Previous studies likely overlooked this mechanism, Yang adds, because of limitations in experimental observations.

Superhydrophobic coatings nearly double the frost propagation time

The researchers also studied the growth rate of the different bridge types. They found that suspended bridges grew slower than bridges on the surface due to the reduced thermal coupling between the bridges and the cold substrate.  This reduced coupling correspondingly reduces the vapour pressure difference between ice and water droplets (which depends on surface droplet geometry, itself controlled by wettability) and drives down ice growth. Indeed, the team found that the speed at which frost spreads fell more than 80% in this mode.

To test the practical relevance of their findings, the researchers applied superhydrophobic coatings to metre-sized structures such as the finned-tube aluminium heat exchangers commonly found in air conditioners, refrigerators and automotive systems. Condensation frosting on such systems poses a major efficiency challenge because frost has an inherently low thermal conductivity. When it accumulates on heat exchangers, it therefore severely impedes heat being exchanged with the surrounding air.

On uncoated commercial heat exchangers that are inherently hydrophilic, the team found that frost rapidly forms and spreads across the fins. “In the superhydrophobic counterparts, however, the onset of frost formation is delayed, and it propagates much more slowly,” Yang says. In the two kinds of commercial systems they tested, she adds, applying superhydrophobic coatings nearly doubled the frost propagation time.

The results suggest that designers of anti-frost surfaces could benefit from trying this new strategy, Yang says. “Rather than focusing solely on delaying initial ice nucleation, surfaces could be engineered to control the geometry of ice-bridge growth and interrupt frost spreading, thereby improving the performance and energy efficiency of a host of equipment operating in cold and humid environments,” she tells Physics World.

The team is now investigating how surface chemistry and surface structures influence suspended ice-bridge formation and frost propagation. “We are also exploring ways to translate the fundamental mechanism into scalable anti-frost coatings and heat-exchanger technologies,” Yang reveals. “Ultimately, our goal is to establish predictive design rules that connect microscale ice-bridge dynamics with real-world frost management performance.”

Does the Bullet Cluster contain a lot less dark matter than we thought?

The Bullet Cluster of galaxies might only have half as much dark matter than scientists thought, or perhaps even none at all, according to a new look at observations of this immense collision of galaxies from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST).

“Our results indicate that the required amount of additional unseen mass – dark matter – is reduced,” astrophysicist Dong Zhang of the University of Bonn, who led the study, tells Physics World.

The Bullet Cluster is a central battleground for proponents of alternative models of gravity seeking to usurp dark-matter theory. The cluster itself is actually two clusters of hundreds of galaxies that have collided head-on. In 2006 the Hubble Space Telescope mapped how the Bullet Cluster’s mass was warping space and creating gravitational lensing, and from this it was possible to infer where the dark matter in the cluster was relative to the galaxies themselves and the hot, X-ray emitting gas. While the galaxies and hot gas remained in the middle, the dark matter from both colliding clusters had passed through unhindered and is now on opposite sides – exactly as dark-matter theory predicted.

In 2025 the JWST observed the Bullet Cluster and the initial analysis, led by Sangjun Cha of Yonsei University, found that while the distribution of mass in the cluster is more complex than expected, it still supports the dark-matter model.

“Those JWST observations of the Bullet Cluster have sparked a lot of interest,” says astrophysicist Richard Massey of Durham University, who was not involved in the new study.

Counting stellar remnants

Astrophysicists led by Zhang have now made their own analysis of the JWST data and arrived at a very different conclusion, as they report in Physical Review D.

Zhang’s team aimed to precisely measure the total mass of not just the stars, but also of dark stellar remnants – white dwarfs, neutron stars and black holes formed when stars die – to see if these objects could account for the extra gravity attributed to dark matter. They found that there would be enough stellar remnants to reduce the amount of dark matter required by half, at least. Furthermore, applying MOND (modified Newtonian dynamics) to the cluster potentially removes the need for dark matter entirely.

They utilized a model called the integrated galaxy-wide initial mass function (IGIMF), which is a variation on the standard IMF that describes how a collapsing molecular cloud fragments into clumps that produce stars. The standard IMF favours low-mass over high-mass stars.

However, variations in chemical compositions, stellar radiation fields and the rate at which gas cools in a given environment mean that the IMF varies from galaxy to galaxy. The IGIMF is designed to get around this by integrating over the full stellar population of a galaxy, or in this case, an entire cluster of galaxies.

“The IGIMF framework was developed independently of MOND and is motivated by observational constraints related to star formation and stellar populations,” says Zhang.

One of the quirks of the IGIMF is that it predicts that in the early universe, more massive stars formed in giant elliptical galaxies than form in galaxies today, consequently producing more stellar remnants than what the standard IMF predicts. Such giant galaxies exist in the core of clusters such as the Bullet. Since massive stars leave behind massive remnants when they go supernova, the gravity of these remnants could account for a large amount of the dark matter. This is supported, says Zhang, by the abundance of heavy elements in some galaxies that’s hard to explain without invoking an early population of very massive stars.

When the quantity of stellar remnants predicted by the IGIMF is applied to the standard model of cosmology “it does not appear sufficient to account for the strong lensing mass in the central regions of the Bullet Cluster,” says Zhang. It is only when applying MOND that things begin to align, he adds.

Questioning the mass function

However, not everyone is convinced by the choice to use the IGIMF over the standard IMF.

“It’s kind of a neat theoretical framework, in which aspects that could produce a total IMF are broken down into separate mathematical terms that can be modelled individually,” says Massey. “But it’s also kind of irrelevant for this sort of empirical analysis, since mainstream analyses already assume that the IMF varies between galaxies, and even in different regions of a galaxy.”

Traditionally, estimating the total stellar mass of a galaxy is accomplished by taking spectra or multi-band photometry and employing a technique called “stellar population synthesis” that best-fits a galaxy’s light to a particular distribution of stellar masses, Massey explains.

“However, the emitted light can be dominated by the brightest, most massive stars,” he says, meaning that the far greater number of less massive stars has to be extrapolated from a galaxy’s stellar mass function, which is derived from the IMF while factoring in the galaxy’s age.

Stellar remnants are even more difficult to detect directly, hence the dependency on the IMF or IGIMF.

“Stellar remnants cannot generally be detected in external galaxies beyond the Milky Way and its satellites,” says Kathy Romer, an astrophysicist at the University of Sussex who studies galaxy clusters. “Exceptions would be via gravitational-wave events or ultra-luminous X-ray binaries, but those are only the tip of the iceberg, so estimates of the total contribution of stellar remnants will always be an extrapolation of what we measure in the Milky Way and Magellanic Clouds.”

Like Massey, who describes IGIMF as being “less mainstream”, Romer is also sceptical about the new results, but acknowledges that “there are some strong aspects to their paper” and that “bringing fresh perspectives and challenging the orthodoxy is essential to keep science moving forward”.

Massey also highlights recent work from a team led by Gregor Rihtarŝiĉ and including Douglas Clowe of Ohio University who led the original Hubble observations of the Bullet Cluster, and who are running simulations to try and refine their maps of dark matter in the cluster.

Copyright © 2026 by IOP Publishing Ltd and individual contributors