More than a quarter of UK university physics departments could be shut down within the next couple of years, according to a survey carried out by the Institute of Physics (IOP). It also reveals that almost 60% of departmental heads expect physics degree courses to close within that time, while more than 80% of those questioned say they expect to see job losses.
The survey findings are published in a new report – Physics Matters: Funding the Foundations of Growth– that says UK university physics is a “major strength” of the UK university system and vital to “national security and technological sovereignty”. The UK currently has about 17,000 physics undergraduates and more than 6000 physics department staff, with about 1 in 20 jobs in the UK using physics-related knowledge and skills.
However, the report adds that this strength cannot be taken for granted and points to “worrying signs” that university physics has started to “punch below its weight”. This is compounded, the IOP says, by a drop in the number of students studying physics at UK universities and flat grant funding for UK physics departments over the past decade.
In addition, UK universities are being hit by financial challenges and funding shortfalls caused by inflationary pressure and a drop in international student numbers. Given that physics comes with high teaching costs, the report states this threatens a “perfect storm” for university physics departments.
Close to breaking point
The survey of 31 departmental heads, which was carried out in August, found that three unnamed departments face imminent closure, with a further 11 anticipating shutting courses. When asked to look ahead over the next two years, eight say they expect to face closure, with 18 anticipating course closures.
Errors in A-level physics papers could jeopardize student university admissions, Institute of Physics warns
One head of physics at a UK university told the IOP, which publishes Physics World, that they are concerned they are “close to breaking point”. “Our university has a £30m deficit,” the anonymous head said. “Staff recruitment is frozen, morale is low. Yet colleagues in our school continue to deliver with less and less and under increasing pressure.”
Jonte Hance, a quantum physicist at Newcastle University, told Physics World that the threat of closures is “horrifying”. In 2004, Newcastle closed its physics department before reopening it over a decade later. “Worryingly, this approach – ignoring, or even cutting, any departments that don’t make a massive short-term profit – doesn’t just seem to be a panicked knee-jerk response on the part of vice-chancellors, but part of a concerted and planned strategy, aiming to turn universities into business incubators,” adds Hance.
Towards a cliff edge
The IOP is now calling on the UK government to commit additional funding for science and engineering departments to help with the operation, maintenance, refurbishment and building of labs and technical facilities. It also wants an “early-warning system” created for departments at risk as well as changes to visa policy to remove international students from net migration figures, retain the graduate visa in its current form, and make “global talent and skilled worker” visas more affordable.
While we understand the pressures on public finances, it would be negligent not to sound the alarm
Keith Burnett
In addition, the IOP wants the UK government to develop a decade-long plan that includes reform of higher-education funding so universities can fund the cost of teaching “important subjects such as physics”. Keith Burnett, the outgoing IOP president, warns that without such action, the UK is “walking towards a cliff edge”, although he believes there is still time to “avert a crisis”.
“While we understand the pressures on public finances, it would be negligent not to sound the alarm for a national capability fundamental to our wellbeing, competitiveness and the defence of the realm,” says Burnett, who is former vice-chancellor at the University of Sheffield and former chair of physics at the University of Oxford. “Physics researchers and talented physics students are our future, but if action isn’t taken now to stabilise, strengthen and sustain one of our greatest national assets, we risk leaving them high and dry.”
