Abraham Atta Ogwu says that learning about morals and ethics will help physicists make better professional judgements
The publication of Isaac Newton’s Principia in 1687 is seen as a major milestone in the separation of physics and natural philosophy. The development was triggered by physics moving into empiricism and the systematic reproducibility of experiments. Philosophy, meanwhile, continued to focus purely on rational and logical attempts to explain occurrences in the natural world.
Universities subsequently separated physics and philosophy into different departments, housing them in different faculties or schools. Despite this move, university physics continues to use aspects of philosophy in its curricula. Examples include idealism, realism, pragmatism and existentialism. Idealism emphasizes rational thinking, logic, abstract concepts and thought experiments used in areas of physics like relativity, quantum mechanics and statistical mechanics.
Realism, meanwhile, is based on empiricism, which involves the collection of observable evidence and the analysis and interpretation of the data collected. Pragmatism spans practical hands-on applications of physics in courses in areas like the industrial applications of physics, computer simulation for real life applications of physics, practice, project and problem-based learning in physics.
There is, however, another major connection between both disciplines that has not been carried over into physics teaching. That is the philosophy of morals and ethics. This is surprising given that physicists are increasingly confronted with issues around the practical application of the philosophy of morals and ethics when making decisions as policy advisers to governments, industries and society at large.
Physicists play a leading role in providing knowledge and advising on issues related to energy, radiation hazards and radioactive-waste management. They also provide input into strategic approaches for the long-term sustainability of our planet. These include questions around increasing the amount of nuclear waste; creating more global warming by using fossil fuels; mining more strategic minerals like lithium for energy; or increasing research funding in physics to seek alternative materials.
In the above cases physicists are faced with making a choice between avoiding harm to the minority in society that will bear the brunt of their recommended actions – known as deontological ethics – or utilitarian ethics such as doing the greater good for most of society, even if it harms the minority. These are part of the philosophical trolley problem that is taught to all philosophy students.
There is also a growing reliance on algorithmic tools like artificial intelligence (AI) by learners and lecturers. We therefore need physicists to use tools from the philosophy of morals and ethics to reflect on the acceptable boundaries of this technology.
A philosophy of ethics course will help professional physicists find the balance between necessity and morality when making professional judgements
There are no easy choices in the above examples when it comes to policy advice, a fact made harder given that physicists are not trained in the philosophy of morals and ethics and how to use them in practice. That is why I believe that all undergraduate physics curricula should include rigorous training in this area.
The best time, in my view, to introduce a philosophy of ethics course is in the second year of an undergraduate physics degree. This is the period when physics students are being introduced to constructivism as a pedagogical approach, in addition to the objectivism that is traditionally used for first-year undergraduate teaching.
Such a course would look at the ethical and moral questions around the future deployment of rapidly evolving developments in physics such as quantum technologies, econophysics and AI on society and the environment. It should do so using philosophical tools like the Socratic method – a form of co-operative, argumentative dialogue.
The perfect time
Physicists will need to be trained both in using their research findings for economic and social benefits to society, and in making the accompanying, sometimes difficult, moral and ethical choices. Training in the philosophy of minimalism and the avoidance of consumerism will bring many benefits to physicists. Physicists with such training will be equipped to focus on delivering better solutions to societal and national problems, and this will reduce the overall financial, materials and environmental cost to society. Why we need to consider the ethical implications of quantum technologies
The philosophy of minimalism in physics is already used in laser-based plasma accelerators, which offer a potential future replacement for large particle accelerators that are kilometres long. Further adoption could result in the development of hand-held, low-cost medical physics devices that could transform healthcare as well as other technologies.
Physics graduates will also benefit from training in virtue ethics, which will make the people they are giving advice to more confident in their judgements.
Introducing a philosophy of ethics course will help professional physicists to find the balance between necessity and morality when making professional judgements and recommendations. Physicists should be trained in normative ethics, applied ethics and meta-ethics to meet societal expectations in their policy advice and decision-making roles. This has already happened in medicine and biology via the introduction of courses in medical ethics, biomedical ethics and bioethics.
It is time it happened in physics too.