The new arXiv?
By Hamish Johnston
Is the love affair with the arXiv preprint server on the wane?
In case you have never heard of it, the arXiv is a vast online repository of physics papers, most of which are uploaded before they have passed muster by peer review. It is seen by many as a shining example of how the Internet can be used to accelerate the dissemination of knowlege — and some see it as a key step in the evolution away from the traditional journal publishing model.
But not everyone is a fan of the Cornell University-based service.
Maverick blogger Tommaso Dorigo is leading a campaign to expose the alleged “blacklisting” of certain researchers, who claim that their papers are not being uploaded to the server — or being relegated to “graveyard” categories.
Oxford University’s Marni Sheppeard — who believes she may be on such a blacklist — has posted a link to an alternative to arXiv called viXra.org.
viXra has just been launched by Phil Gibbs (who I think is an independent physicist) and contains one paper — an essay entitled This Time – What a Strange Turn of Events! by Phil Gibbs.
Elsewhere in the blogosphere, David Bacon calls for more transparency in the arXiv’s editorial policies.
So, are Tommaso, Marni, Phil and David just a few dissenting voices in an otherwise happy physics community, or is the love affair with arXiv waning?
I’m sure this is a completely unrelated incident — but Bacon also asks has the arXiv been hacked?.
