Skip to main content
Everyday science

Everyday science

Blacklisted?

09 Jul 2009 Hamish Johnston
vixra.jpg
The new arXiv?

By Hamish Johnston

Is the love affair with the arXiv preprint server on the wane?

In case you have never heard of it, the arXiv is a vast online repository of physics papers, most of which are uploaded before they have passed muster by peer review. It is seen by many as a shining example of how the Internet can be used to accelerate the dissemination of knowlege — and some see it as a key step in the evolution away from the traditional journal publishing model.

But not everyone is a fan of the Cornell University-based service.

Maverick blogger Tommaso Dorigo is leading a campaign to expose the alleged “blacklisting” of certain researchers, who claim that their papers are not being uploaded to the server — or being relegated to “graveyard” categories.

Oxford University’s Marni Sheppeard — who believes she may be on such a blacklist — has posted a link to an alternative to arXiv called viXra.org.

viXra has just been launched by Phil Gibbs (who I think is an independent physicist) and contains one paper — an essay entitled This Time – What a Strange Turn of Events! by Phil Gibbs.

Elsewhere in the blogosphere, David Bacon calls for more transparency in the arXiv’s editorial policies.

So, are Tommaso, Marni, Phil and David just a few dissenting voices in an otherwise happy physics community, or is the love affair with arXiv waning?

I’m sure this is a completely unrelated incident — but Bacon also asks has the arXiv been hacked?.

Copyright © 2024 by IOP Publishing Ltd and individual contributors