Skip to main content
Cosmology

Cosmology

Rapidly rotating black holes could ‘wear pants’, say theorists

Illustration of a black hole splitting in two black holes that looks like a pair of trousers or pants. A clock and an arrow pointing from the
Who wears the pants here? Illustration of a black hole splitting in two over time, creating a track that resembles a pair of trousers or pants. (Courtesy: Francesco Sannino)

We usually think of black holes as objects that either swallow everything in their vicinity or catastrophically collide and merge with each other. But could a single black hole ever split into two smaller black holes instead? New calculations by theoretical physicists in Italy, Denmark and France offer the beginnings of an answer to this question. Their work, which outlines the conditions that might make black hole splitting possible, could help us better understand primordial black holes and the workings of gravity at a fundamental level.

In four-dimensional classical general relativity, stationary black holes (also known as Schwartzchild black holes) are remarkably rigid, so they do not normally split. The late physicist Stephen Hawking explained their stability using his area theorem, which states that splitting would decrease the total entropy stored in the black holes – a thermodynamically unfavourable outcome. Hawking’s conclusion has recently received support from direct observations of the gravitational signal of binary black hole mergers, and there are theoretical reasons why it should also apply to Kerr black holes, which are slowly spinning.

A waist branching into two legs

For black holes that are rotating near their maximum possible rate, however, the picture is not so straightforward. According to a team led by Francesco Sannino of the University of Naples Federico II in Italy and the Quantum Field Theory Center at the University of Southern Denmark, these black holes could split in two like the waist on a pair of pants branching into two legs – albeit only under strict conditions.

“The entropy of the system must not decrease, and the energy and the angular momentum of the spinning black hole must be conserved,” Sannino explains. “The formed fragments also need enough energy to escape from each other, and a split could easily fail this last test if gravity simply brought them back together.”

The fact that a rapidly rotating black hole has a reservoir of rotational energy makes it a particularly interesting candidate for splitting, Sannino adds. Some of this rotational energy could, in principle, be translated into orbital motion of the fragments, but again, the process wouldn’t be simple. “Providing the fragments with enough energy to escape makes fragmentation much more difficult than entropy alone suggests,” he tells Physics World. “In our analysis, this scenario is only possible very close to the maximum allowed spin. This identifies a regime worth investigating – although it does not establish with complete certainty that rapidly spinning black holes split or overturn the classical restrictions on so-called event-horizon splitting.”

Other scenarios in which black holes can “wear pants”

In their study, which they describe in Physical Review D, Sannino and colleagues also explored other scenarios in which black holes can, in the jargon of the field, “wear pants”. They found that in some extensions to classical general relativity, producing a small black hole “morsel” can increase the system’s total entropy, and therefore allow it to fragment.

Splitting is also possible in theories of general relativity that involve additional spatial dimensions. According to these theories, black-hole-like objects can become unstable and break apart, especially in situations where one of the black hole “legs” has a much smaller mass than the other. “Again, this does not mean that fragmentation will actually happen,” Sannino cautions. “It all depends on how gravity behaves beyond Einstein’s theory.”

With that caveat, Sannino says that for higher-dimensional black-hole-like objects known as black strings, fragmentation might involve a phenomenon known as a Gregory–Laflamme instability. Another possibly pants-wearing group of black holes, termed ultra-spinning Myers–Perry black holes, is prone to fragmentation because of event horizons that tend towards highly inhomogeneous configurations with endpoints that can pinch off. Finally, Sannino and his colleagues think that small, early-universe black holes may be more liable to split than the much larger black holes that formed later.

Sannino and his Southern Denmark colleagues Manuel Del Piano and Vania Vellucci, together with Giacomo Cacciapaglia at the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS)-Laboratoire de Physique Théorique et Hautes Énergies, now plan to use calculations and numerical simulations to explore whether any of these scenarios actually produce black-hole fragments. They also think it might be possible to detect black hole splits indirectly using gamma-ray telescopes such as the Fermi Large Area Telescope (Fermi-LAT).

In a related study, they attempted to do just that, combing Fermi-LAT data for delayed gamma-ray signals derived from hypothetical small black-hole morsels left behind after black hole mergers. Although they didn’t find any, they succeeded in placing limits on this scenario, and Sannino says their next step will be to extend their search to more mergers.

Back to Cosmology Cosmology
Copyright © 2026 by IOP Publishing Ltd and individual contributors