Signs of an exotic atom-like system made up of a neutral meson bound to an atomic nucleus via the strong interaction have emerged in experimental data from two international collaborations. If confirmed, this hitherto unobserved system could shed light on the origins of hadron masses and provide new insights into the fundamental symmetries of quantum chromodynamics in nuclear matter.
The strong interaction is one of the four fundamental forces of nature, alongside gravity, electromagnetism and the weak interaction. It is responsible for binding quarks into hadrons, which are three-quark particles such as protons and neutrons, and for holding protons and neutrons together within atomic nuclei. Electrically neutral mesons – short-lived particles made up of a quark and an antiquark – are likewise subject to the strong interaction, which can bind them to atomic nuclei in a way that is conceptually similar to an electron bound to a nucleus by the electromagnetic force.
Studying these meson-based nuclear systems is important because it helps us better understand the properties of the strong interaction, says study co-leader Yoshiki Tanaka of RIKEN in Japan. The eta prime meson, η′, is particularly interesting, Tanaka adds, because its relatively large mass cannot be explained by a simple quark model. “This U(1) problem, as it known, was raised as long ago as the 1970s by the physicist Steven Weinberg,” he notes.
Direct experimental access to the 𝜂′-meson mass in nuclei
Modern theories attribute the η′ meson’s large mass to the presence of chiral symmetry breaking in quantum chromodynamics, which is the fundamental theory of the strong force. These theories predict that this mass should be reduced in a nuclear system, and this is what Tanaka and colleagues set out to test.
“Spectroscopy studies of 𝜂′-mesic nuclei provide direct experimental access to the 𝜂′-meson mass in nuclei and offer a unique opportunity to investigate the underlying mechanisms of how the mass of hadrons comes about,” he explains.
In the team’s study, a beam of protons strikes a ¹²C atomic nucleus at near-relativistic speeds and removes a neutron from it. This neutron, together with a proton, forms a deuteron that propagates away in a forward direction, leaving behind a nucleus of ¹¹C in a highly energetic state. It is this excess energy that gives rise to an 𝜂′-meson.
In rare cases, the researchers explain, the meson then binds to the ¹¹C nucleus, forming an 𝜂′-mesic nuclear system. But because these events are so rare, they are hard to find. “One of the major challenges we encountered in the work was the very large amount of background events we registered during our measurements,” Tanaka recalls. “These were about 100 to 1000 times higher than the signal events.”
The researchers overcame this problem by developing a new experiment that allows them to efficiently select signal events associated with the formation of 𝜂′-mesic nuclei by “tagging” the particles they decay into. This enabled them to measure not only the forward-travelling deuteron, but also the decay products of the short-lived 𝜂′-mesic nuclear state.
Tetraquark measurements could shed more light on the strong nuclear force
The researchers say that their results, which they describe in Physical Review Letters, indicate that the 𝜂′-meson mass drops by about 60 MeV in nuclear matter. “This result qualitatively supports the theoretical scenario [that attributes] the origin of the 𝜂′-meson mass to chiral symmetry breaking together with the dynamics of gluons (massless particles that mediate the strong nuclear force) in general,” Tanaka says.
Members of the team, which also includes researchers from the η-PRiME Collaboration and the Super Fragment Separator Experiment Collaboration, together with physicists from Justus Liebig University Giessen in Germany with their working groups GSI/FAIR, say they are now planning follow-up experiments to confirm that they have indeed observed 𝜂′-mesic nuclei. “We also aim to increase the significance to the 5σ level, which is required to firmly establish the discovery on new quantum states in particle and nuclear physics,” Tanaka says.
